Were German Americans Put In Internment Camps

6 min read

The question of whether German Americans were placed in internment camps during World War II often surprises those familiar only with the incarceration of Japanese Americans. The short answer is yes, the United States government did intern German Americans and German nationals, though the scale, legal framework, and public memory differ significantly from the Japanese American experience. Understanding this chapter requires examining the Alien Enemy Act of 1798, the distinction between "enemy aliens" and citizens, and the specific policies that led to the detention of over 11,000 people of German ancestry.

The Legal Foundation: The Alien Enemy Act

The authority for internment did not originate with Executive Order 9066, the directive famously used to authorize the removal of Japanese Americans from the West Coast. Instead, the internment of German nationals—and by extension, their American-born family members—relied on the Alien Enemy Act of 1798. This statute, still in effect today, allows the president to apprehend, restrain, secure, and remove "alien enemies" upon declaration of war or invasion.

When the U.S. entered World War II in December 1941, German nationals living in the U.In practice, s. Here's the thing — who had not naturalized were immediately classified as "enemy aliens. Plus, " Under Presidential Proclamations 2525, 2526, and 2526, the Department of Justice was granted sweeping authority to arrest and detain these individuals without the due process protections typically afforded criminal defendants. This legal distinction is critical: the government interned alien enemies based on nationality, whereas the Japanese American internment (under Executive Order 9066) targeted both aliens and citizens based on ancestry and military necessity arguments.

Who Was Interned? The Numbers and Demographics

Approximately 11,507 people of German ancestry were interned during the war. This figure includes German nationals (citizens of Germany) and a smaller number of German Americans who voluntarily accompanied interned family members or were detained under specific suspicion Easy to understand, harder to ignore..

The demographic breakdown reveals a crucial nuance:

  • German Nationals: The vast majority were legal permanent residents who had lived in the U.S. In practice, for decades but had not completed naturalization. Many were elderly, had American-born children, and considered themselves fully integrated.
  • Latin American Deportees: A significant and often overlooked group—over 4,000 Germans—were seized from Latin American countries (primarily Bolivia, Colombia, Costa Rica, and Panama) at the behest of the U.S. State Department. That's why they were transported to the U. S. and interned, often to be used in prisoner exchanges with the Third Reich.
  • American Citizens: Unlike Japanese Americans, U.On the flip side, s. Consider this: citizens of German descent were not subject to mass exclusion orders. Still, minor children and spouses of interned aliens often "voluntarily" joined them in camps to keep families together, effectively becoming internees themselves.

The Internment Process: Hearings and Camps

The process for German aliens differed from the summary removal of Japanese Americans. The Department of Justice established Alien Enemy Hearing Boards across the country. These boards reviewed the cases of arrested aliens. Also, while this sounds like due process, the hearings were heavily stacked against the detainee:

  • The burden of proof was on the alien to prove they were not dangerous. * Detainees were not allowed legal counsel.
  • Evidence against them was often classified or based on anonymous informants (sometimes neighbors with personal grudges).
  • Membership in German cultural societies, subscription to German newspapers, or possession of a shortwave radio could be cited as "evidence" of disloyalty.

Short version: it depends. Long version — keep reading.

If the board recommended internment, the Attorney General made the final decision. Which means internees were then sent to a network of camps run by the Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) and the U. Practically speaking, s. Army.

Major Internment Camps for German Americans included:

  • Fort Lincoln, North Dakota: One of the largest, holding over 1,800 internees at its peak.
  • Crystal City, Texas: A unique "family internment camp" designed to house entire families, including those deported from Latin America. It had schools, a hospital, and even a swimming pool, but it remained a prison surrounded by barbed wire and armed guards.
  • Fort Missoula, Montana: Initially held Italian and Japanese aliens, later German internees.
  • Stringtown, Oklahoma: An early camp converted from a state prison.
  • Ellis Island, New York: Used as a transit and detention center for those arriving from Latin America or awaiting hearings/deportation.

Life Inside the Camps

Conditions in the Department of Justice camps generally met Geneva Convention standards for prisoner-of-war treatment, which was often better than the War Relocation Authority (WRA) camps housing Japanese Americans. Internees had more autonomy: they organized their own educational classes, published newspapers, ran mess halls, and maintained gardens.

On the flip side, the psychological toll was severe. Plus, internees faced:

  • Indefinite Detention: No fixed sentence; release depended on a review board or the war's end. * Family Separation: Men were often arrested suddenly at work or home, leaving wives and children destitute and unaware of their husband's location for weeks.
  • Loss of Livelihood: Assets were frequently frozen, businesses lost, and professional licenses revoked.
  • Stigma: The "enemy alien" label followed them after release, damaging reputations and careers.

Short version: it depends. Long version — keep reading.

The "Voluntary" Internment of Families

A distinct feature of the German American experience was the "voluntary" internment of women and children. Worth adding: the INS offered "family internment" at Crystal City as a solution. Day to day, because the Alien Enemy Act applied only to aliens, the government could not legally force American-born wives and children into camps. Practically speaking, while technically voluntary, the coercive economic pressure made the choice illusory for many. Still, when the primary breadwinner was arrested and assets frozen, families faced destitution. This created a unique population of American citizens living behind barbed wire without individual charges or hearings And it works..

Comparison with Japanese American Internment

Contextualize the German American experience without equating it to the Japanese American experience — this one isn't optional. Key differences include:

Feature German American Internment Japanese American Internment
Legal Basis Alien Enemy Act (1798) - Nationality based Executive Order 9066 - "Military Necessity" / Ancestry based
**Citizens Targeted?S. Consider this: ** No mass internment of citizens Yes, ~70,000+ U. citizens incarcerated
Scale ~11,500 total (incl.

The Japanese American internment was a racialized, geographic expulsion of an entire community—citizens and aliens alike—from the West Coast. The German American internment was a selective, individualized (though often flawed) process targeting alien enemies nationwide. On the flip side, the lack of due process, the use of secret evidence, and the internment of Latin American deportees represent serious civil liberties violations that mirror the broader injustices of the era.

The Latin American Connection: A Hidden Chapter

One of the most disturbing aspects of this history is the Latin American Program. The U.S. government pressured Latin American nations to arrest their German residents—many of whom were citizens of those countries—and hand them over to U.S. authorities. The State Department wanted these individuals for a prisoner exchange program with Nazi Germany Simple, but easy to overlook..

Because the U.S. had more German prisoners than Germany had American prisoners, the U

Up Next

Hot Topics

In the Same Zone

Picked Just for You

Thank you for reading about Were German Americans Put In Internment Camps. We hope the information has been useful. Feel free to contact us if you have any questions. See you next time — don't forget to bookmark!
⌂ Back to Home