Was John Wilkes Booth A Democrat

6 min read

The question of John Wilkes Booth’s political affiliation is one that surfaces frequently in historical debates, often fueled by a desire to draw direct lines between the fractious politics of the 1860s and the partisan divides of today. Because of that, the short answer is that Booth was not a member of the Democratic Party in any formal, organized sense during the years leading up to the assassination of Abraham Lincoln. That said, reducing his ideology to a simple party label misses the complex, volatile, and deeply personal nature of his political radicalization. To understand Booth, one must look beyond party registration cards—which did not exist in the modern sense—and examine his public statements, his family background, his theatrical circle, and the specific grievances that drove him to commit the first presidential assassination in American history Which is the point..

The Political Landscape of the 1850s and 1860s

Before analyzing Booth himself, Understand the chaotic political realignment of the era — this one isn't optional. Worth adding: the Second Party System (Democrats vs. Whigs) collapsed in the mid-1850s over the issue of slavery expansion. The Whig Party disintegrated, giving rise to the Republican Party in the North and the Know Nothing (American) Party as a major nativist force. The Democratic Party split in 1860 into Northern and Southern factions, running Stephen Douglas and John C. Breckinridge respectively.

In Maryland, Booth’s home state, politics were intensely localized and violent. Maryland was a border slave state that did not secede, largely due to the suspension of habeas corpus and the occupation of Baltimore by Union troops. Day to day, this party was anti-immigrant, anti-Catholic, and pro-slavery (or at least pro-states' rights regarding slavery). In practice, the dominant political force in Baltimore during Booth’s youth was the Know Nothing movement, formally known as the American Party. Booth’s father, Junius Brutus Booth, and his brothers were known to have sympathies aligned with the South, but the family’s political identity was more accurately described as "Southern Rights" or "States' Rights" rather than strictly "Democratic Worth keeping that in mind..

Worth pausing on this one.

Booth’s Early Allegiances: The Know Nothing Connection

Historical evidence suggests that in the mid-1850s, a young John Wilkes Booth was associated with the Know Nothing Party. In 1854, at the age of 16, he reportedly participated in a Know Nothing parade in Baltimore. By 1856, he was writing letters expressing strong nativist sentiments, railing against immigration and the influence of the Catholic Church—hallmarks of the American Party platform Most people skip this — try not to..

This affiliation is crucial because the Know Nothings were not Democrats. Even so, in many Northern cities, they were the primary opposition to the Democrats, absorbing anti-slavery voters who were not yet ready to join the Republicans. Worth adding: in the South, however, the Know Nothings often functioned as a unionist alternative to the Democrats, attracting former Whigs who wanted to preserve the Union but maintain slavery. Booth’s attraction to the movement likely stemmed from its nativist, nationalist fervor and its strong presence in Baltimore’s volatile street politics, rather than a deep commitment to its specific platform.

The Shift to Secessionism and the "Southern Rights" Doctrine

As the sectional crisis deepened, Booth’s politics hardened into a fierce advocacy for the Confederacy. He did not switch to the Democratic Party; rather, he embraced the cause of Southern independence. Still, by 1859, he had joined a Virginia militia unit, the Richmond Grays, to witness the execution of John Brown at Harpers Ferry. This event was a turning point. Booth viewed Brown not as a martyr, but as a traitor and a murderer, and he saw the Northern reaction to Brown’s raid as proof of the North’s hostility toward the South Easy to understand, harder to ignore..

Most guides skip this. Don't.

During the 1860 election, Booth supported John C. Breckinridge, the Southern Democratic candidate. This is the primary source of the claim that he was a "Democrat." On the flip side, voting for Breckinridge in 1860 was an act of sectional loyalty, not necessarily partisan loyalty. Which means the Southern Democratic ticket represented the explicit protection of slavery and the right of secession. On the flip side, booth’s support was for the platform of slavery expansion and states' rights, not for the Democratic Party as an institution. In fact, many former Whigs and Know Nothings in the Deep South voted for Breckinridge because he was the only viable pro-slavery candidate.

The War Years: A Confederate Sympathizer Behind Enemy Lines

Once the war began, Booth remained in the North, pursuing his acting career while secretly functioning as a Confederate agent and smuggler. His political identity during these years was Confederate nationalist. He corresponded with Confederate sympathizers, helped run the blockade to bring quinine and other supplies South, and reportedly met with Confederate leadership in Montreal It's one of those things that adds up..

His hatred for Abraham Lincoln intensified throughout the war. He viewed Lincoln as a tyrant, a usurper of the Constitution, and the architect of the South’s destruction. Booth’s opposition to Lincoln was not rooted in Democratic Party talking points—such as opposition to a national bank or tariff policy—but in the President’s prosecution of the war, the Emancipation Proclamation, and the enlistment of Black soldiers Easy to understand, harder to ignore. No workaround needed..

In a letter written to his sister Asia in 1865, Booth articulated his worldview: "This country was formed for the white, not for the black man. And looking upon African slavery from the same standpoint held by those noble framers of our Constitution, I for one have ever considered it one of the greatest blessings that God has ever bestowed upon a favored nation." This rhetoric—white supremacy, a strict constructionist view of the Constitution favoring slavery, and a belief in the divine right of the Southern cause—transcended party labels. It was the ideology of the Confederacy.

The Assassination: Political Theater, Not Partisan Hit

When Booth shot Lincoln at Ford’s Theatre on April 14, 1865, he shouted "Sic semper tyrannis" (Thus always to tyrants)—the Virginia state motto—and "The South is avenged." He did not shout a party slogan. Practically speaking, he did not reference Democratic platforms. He framed the act as a blow for Southern independence and a punishment for a man he viewed as a monarchical tyrant.

His co-conspirators were a mix of Confederate veterans, Southern sympathizers, and opportunists. None were operating under the direction of the Democratic Party leadership. In fact, prominent Northern Democrats (often called "War Democrats" or "Peace Democrats/Copperheads") universally condemned the assassination. Figures like Horatio Seymour and George McClellan denounced the act immediately, recognizing that it destroyed any hope for a lenient Reconstruction and painted all opposition to Lincoln with the brush of treason.

Why the "Democrat" Label Persists

If Booth was not a card-carrying Democrat, why is the label so persistent in modern discourse?

  1. The 1860 Vote: Going back to this, he voted for Breckinridge. In the binary of modern politics, the 1860 election is often simplified to "Lincoln (Republican) vs. Douglas/Breckinridge (Democrats)." This flattens the four-way race and ignores the Constitutional Union ticket (John Bell) which carried the border states of Virginia, Kentucky, and Tennessee.
  2. Post-War Partisan Narrative: After the war, Republicans used the "bloody shirt" strategy, reminding voters that the Rebellion and the assassination were the fruits of Democratic treason. Democrats countered by emphasizing Lincoln’s tyranny. Over 150 years, this calcified into a meme: Lincoln was a Republican; Booth killed him; therefore Booth was a Democrat.
  3. Confusion with the "Copperheads": The Peace Democrats (Copperheads) opposed the war and Lincoln’s policies. Booth shared their hatred of Lincoln, but he was not a Copperhead. Copperheads generally wanted
Hot Off the Press

Hot Off the Blog

Curated Picks

You Might Also Like

Thank you for reading about Was John Wilkes Booth A Democrat. We hope the information has been useful. Feel free to contact us if you have any questions. See you next time — don't forget to bookmark!
⌂ Back to Home