The first Thanksgiving, as commonly imagined, is a blend of oral tradition, schoolbook pageants, and historical fact. In practice, at the heart of many modern questions lies a specific, often overlooked detail: how many women were at the first Thanksgiving? To answer this, we must travel back to autumn 1621 in Plymouth Colony, examine the surviving primary sources, and separate myth from documented reality. Practically speaking, the feast celebrated a successful harvest, but its participants list reveals much about the fragile social fabric of early colonial life, the survival rates of English women, and the crucial role of the Wampanoag people. Understanding the actual number of women present not only corrects historical misconceptions but also honors the often-unseen contributions of women to the colony's survival.
The 1621 harvest feast was not yet called "Thanksgiving" by the participants, nor was it the singular, gender-balanced family gathering portrayed in popular culture. Instead, it was a multi-day event of eating, shooting contests, and diplomacy between about 50 English colonists and 90 Wampanoag men. The English group consisted largely of men who had survived the first winter, a period during which disease and starvation decimated the original Mayflower company. So naturally, of the roughly 100 men, women, and children who had arrived on the Mayflower in 1620, only about half lived to see the autumn of 1621. Among those who survived, women were a distinct minority, and their numbers are specifically recorded in the colony's early journals.
The most detailed account of the 1621 feast comes from Edward Winslow, a Plymouth Colony leader, who wrote about the event in Mourt's Relation, a pamphlet published in 1622 to attract investors and settlers. So winslow's description mentions that the governor, William Bradford, sent four men on a "fowling" mission to prepare for the feast. He also notes that the Wampanoag leader Massasoit arrived with about 90 men, and that the English and their guests hunted, feasted, and exchanged gifts over three days. Nowhere in Winslow's or Bradford's later writings is there a tallies of women present, but the context strongly suggests their presence was limited. The silence on gender counts in the primary records is itself informative: it reflects the reality that women's roles and numbers were often taken for granted or recorded differently in colonial documentation Worth keeping that in mind..
Historical reconstruction, cross-referencing Of Plymouth Plantation and Mourt's Relation, indicates that only about four to five English women were living in Plymouth by 1621. These women were likely Alice Carpenter Southworth, Elizabeth Hopkins, and possibly a few others whose names have not survived in the colonial records. Even so, to put this in perspective: of the approximately 19 women who had arrived on the Mayflower, only a small fraction endured the first winter, which claimed the lives of roughly half the colony, including many women and children. The survival of these few women was critical, not only for maintaining household operations but also for ensuring the colony's long-term continuity through childbirth, food preparation, and the transmission of cultural practices.
The limited number of women at the first Thanksgiving underscores the gendered nature of early colonial survival. That's why men were often the ones documented in land grants, military exercises, and diplomatic missions, while women's labor—cooking, gardening, nursing, textile production—was essential but less frequently named in the written record. The four to five women present at the 1621 feast would have been responsible for much of the food preparation, including the cooking of fowl, corn, and shellfish that featured prominently in the celebration.