Against Such Things There Is No Law Meaning

6 min read

Against Such Things There Is No Law: When Evil Outrages Legal Boundaries

The phrase "against such things there is no law" is not a statement of legal nihilism, but rather a profound acknowledgment of a terrifying reality: some acts are so heinous, so fundamentally evil, that they exist in a category beyond the reach of any written statute. And this concept, famously echoed in Shakespeare's King Lear where the character describes the "unnatural" crimes of Goneril and Regan, points to a critical flaw in any legal system that assumes it can codify all human wrongdoing. It suggests that true justice sometimes requires recognizing that certain atrocities are lex lacrimae—laws written in tears—transcending the mere letter of the law Which is the point..

To understand this idea is to confront the limits of human systems designed to maintain order. Laws are man-made constructs, designed by societies to govern behavior, protect rights, and establish norms. Which means they are inherently limited, bound by the understanding and moral compass of their creators at the time of their inception. Also, what happens when a crime is so extreme, so dehumanizing, that it doesn't just break a specific rule but seems to violate a fundamental, unwritten principle of humanity itself? This is the territory where "against such things there is no law" finds its power The details matter here..

The Origin and Literary Weight

The sentiment predates Shakespeare, but his use in King Lear provides its most famous articulation. Lear, betrayed by his daughters, cries out in his madness:

"O, let me not be mad, not mad, thou dear heaven! Our basest fears, our shame, our worst desires, We hold our lives in estimation, and we rate Our wrongs according to their true deserving; And then, for the extremity of ill, Against such things there is no law."

Here, Lear is not saying that laws do not exist. Consider this: the law, with its categories of assault, theft, or treason, cannot possibly measure or rectify the depth of this moral violation. He is expressing a deeper, more existential despair. The crime is not just against a person, but against the very fabric of familial love and natural order. The "extremity of ill"—the profound betrayal, the psychological torture, the stripping away of love and respect—is so overwhelming that it renders all legal concepts of justice and punishment inadequate. In this context, the law is silent because the offense is a sin against a cosmic order, not merely a crime against the state Most people skip this — try not to..

Modern Applications: Crimes Against Humanity

While King Lear deals with a domestic tragedy, the principle applies on a global scale. The most potent modern examples are found in international law and the prosecution of crimes against humanity and genocide.

Consider the Holocaust. Was it a violation of German law? At the time, many of the Nuremberg Laws were legal under the German state. The systematic murder of six million Jews was an act of state policy. Yet, the world recognized that these acts were so abhorrent that they could not be considered lawful, regardless of what the domestic legal system said. That said, the post-war Nuremberg Trials established the precedent that individuals could be held accountable for crimes against humanity, even if those acts were legal under the government that ordered them. The phrase "against such things there is no law" captures this perfectly: the legal framework of Nazi Germany was itself the instrument of evil. True law, in the moral sense, was on the side of the victims, and the perpetrators' actions were anathema to any concept of justice.

Similarly, acts of torture are often prohibited by international law, but even when a state attempts to legalize or justify them (as in the "torture memos" of the US government post-9/11), the global community recoils. Still, it is a principle so fundamental that it overrides all other laws. The prohibition against torture is considered a jus cogens norm—a peremptory norm of international law from which no derogation is permitted. This is the essence of the phrase: some principles are so inviolable that any law permitting their violation is not law at all, but a perversion of law Surprisingly effective..

Short version: it depends. Long version — keep reading.

The Erosion of Legal Frameworks by Systemic Evil

The phrase also warns against the corruption of legal systems themselves. When a state becomes an instrument of oppression, the law can be twisted to legitimize atrocity. Because of that, Apartheid in South Africa was a legal system, but it was a system of brutal racial segregation. Also, the international community did not recognize the legitimacy of these laws, viewing them as a crime against humanity. The law, in this case, was not a shield for the oppressed but a weapon for the oppressor Most people skip this — try not to. Nothing fancy..

This leads to a crucial distinction: the difference between positive law (what is written down and enforced by a state) and natural law (the inherent sense of justice and morality that exists independent of human statutes). The concept behind "against such things there is no law" aligns with natural law theory. " As the philosopher St. It posits that if a positive law is fundamentally unjust—if it sanctions torture, genocide, or enslavement—it forfeits its claim to be called "law.Thomas Aquinas argued, an unjust law is no law at all Simple, but easy to overlook..

Counterarguments and the Danger of Subjectivity

Of course, this is a dangerous concept. Who decides what is "against all law"? Day to day, the appeal to a higher law can be used to justify vigilantism or the overthrow of a legal system one dislikes. Critics argue that it introduces an element of subjectivity and can undermine the rule of law, which depends on clear, objective statutes Worth keeping that in mind..

Still, the international community has grappled with this by establishing frameworks like the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (ICC), which defines specific, universally condemned acts. The principle is not meant to be a free-for-all but a recognition that there is a floor of human decency below which no legal system should sink. It is a safeguard against the ultimate abuse of power: the power to make evil legal Which is the point..

Conclusion: The Moral Compass Beyond the Code

"Against such things there is no law" is ultimately a call for moral courage. It reminds us that our legal systems are imperfect tools, and that our ultimate guide must be a conscience informed by a universal understanding of human rights and dignity. When faced with an atrocity that seems to mock the very idea of justice, we must have the courage to say that the law, as written, is insufficient. We must appeal to a higher standard That's the part that actually makes a difference..

This phrase does not advocate for lawlessness; it advocates for a deeper, more profound sense of law—a law written on the human heart. It is a declaration that certain evils are so great that they cannot be contained by any human-made code. Consider this: they can only be met with a global, moral imperative for justice that transcends borders and statutes. In recognizing that there is "no law" against such things, we are actually affirming the existence of a law far greater than any that can be penned: the law of our shared humanity.

Coming In Hot

Hot off the Keyboard

Worth Exploring Next

Topics That Connect

Thank you for reading about Against Such Things There Is No Law Meaning. We hope the information has been useful. Feel free to contact us if you have any questions. See you next time — don't forget to bookmark!
⌂ Back to Home